It seems that all my friends are out shopping for Christmas trees this weekend. Our family celebrates Christmas, too, and both my husband and I grew up with presents under a Christmas tree. Selecting the perfect tree from the Hunter Tree Farm lot behind our neighborhood post office was absolute fun for my brother and me when we were kids. Too tall? Too small? Too much like a Charlie Brown Christmas tree? No problem, try the next row of Doug fir trees. Nope, we never did the Noble firs.Now, a question about the ecological impact of Christmas trees from one of my co-workers at Resource Media and an article in TIME magazine got me thinking about what exactly is the most eco-friendly way to celebrate Christmas with a decorated tree. No, I’m not going to be a grinch about this. A decorated tree is one tradition I do want to keep for my family in one form or another.After doing a bit of research (but, not a whole lot because I’ve got to tend to getting my Christmas cards out soon and, yes, I send them via email complete with lovely family photo!), I have come to find this so just a wee bit more complicated than simply a choice between buying a tree from a tree farm versus buying an artificial tree that will last you for 20 years. There are choices out there, folks! And, some surprises, too, if you read on.
With Christmas trees, my personal solution is to decorate an existing tree in our garden for the utter and wonderful enjoyment of our neighbors and those who walk by with their dogs (truth be told, no anecdotal evidence yet as to whether the neighborhood thinks our tree is a nice addition to the ‘hood or whether we’ve taken it down to the pink flamingo on the lawn level). If you don’t have the right tree in your yard, or a hearty indoor plant that can handle at least 5 ornaments dangling from its branches, but you are excited by the idea of adding another tree to your yard, you could go to your local nursery to find a native plant that will look nice inside for a few weeks and even better outside this spring.
But, what to do with the presents that normally get laid out below the tree if you decorate an outdoor tree? Well, we have a fireplace and will nicely arrange them in a semi-circle in front of the hearth. And, there will be some nice decorations inside the house. This morning’s gingerbread house being the first.
Rest assured, my very limited research shows that no matter what your choice, it’s all kind of a wash. Christmas tree farms are a form of sustainable forestry. Out here in the Pacific Northwest, where Douglas fir trees grow fairly quickly, buying one typically means you are supporting a rural business and your tree did not travel far from farm to hearth. But, be sure to recycle/compost your tree after Christmas!
Now, a friend at Thanksgiving asked whether your average tree farm fir may be sprayed with flame retardant. Yikes! I went on the Internet to do a little sleuthing to see if these are applied before the tree comes into your home. Nothing definitive here as to whether your tree comes with fire retardant, best to ask your tree seller. But, I could see that there is a market for selling people fire retardant that you can spray on the tree AFTER you buy it. My advice is to save your money and your health and instead keep the tree in water. It’ll keep those pesky needles off your carpet, too, for at least a few weeks.
An artificial tree will very likely come from quite far afield – China, perhaps. So, the carbon footprint will be significantly larger. Plus, there may be some nasty chemicals in the plastic. PVC’s – yuck. And, those puppies aren’t biodegradable, either.
I told another friend at a holiday party about our choice of decorating our tree outside. She said that’s all well and good, but what if you were her and had no desire to have a fir tree or any other native tree in the yard? To that, I say, gee, I wish we all lived in Portland, Oregon, where you can rent potted trees and then they get picked up after Christmas and planted on school property, parks and other public places (as detailed in the TIME magazine article).
So, if you want to do something good this Christmas, how about calling your municipality to make sure they have a tree-recycling program or, better yet, that a project like the Original Living Christmas Tree Co. of Portland also gets started in your community.
Oh, Christmas tree, oh, Christmas tree, how lovely are your branches…